I have heard about Hamilton for a couple of years, and have looked a couple of times at the possibility of seeing it, but in addition to baulking at the price, I never made it to a city where I had the chance to watch it. So when an ad popped up that it was going to be on Disney plus, where I had been watching Winnie-the-Pooh a little too often with my daughter, I was thrilled. I realized that one of my reservations was that no matter where I saw it, it wouldn't be the original cast, but this version, filmed in 2017, made it possible to turn back time.
I am bowled over by the production. It is a simple idea. Follow the life of an extraordinary man in extraordinary times. The storytelling is compelling. Start strong, introduce him by his friends and enemies, teach us something, move us with his brilliance and flaws. He is a hero, writing his legacy without knowing anyone would remember him. Desperate to make a difference, he is told he shouldn't be so honest, so driven, so much. He has to swallow condescension and racism to prove himself. He is passionate and too loud and immodest. Even if we had no idea who he was at the beginning, we are convinced about his influence during the birth of America, and it's hard not to finish the musical without liking, or admiring the man.
It's a timely piece with our own revolution happening with #blacklives matters. It's a refreshing change to have so many major players in the script being actors of colour. Washington, Lafayette, Hamilton, and Madison are reinterpreted, but the imagination ends within the male gender. I can't help but be sad for the superficial treatment of women and their general irrelevance. They are dressed in their corsets or ball gowns, serving as sex objects or chattel. The closest we get is Angelica singing about asking Thomas Jefferson for a sequel for women when the revolution results in equalizing all men.
Still, the cast is half men and half women, and although their roles are smaller, the unrequited love of Angelica, and the forgiveness and grief of Elizabeth make the story richer and brought me to tears on several occasions. There are moments of total camaraderie, bald truth, verbal sparing, admirable character, and even levity. Even the moment of his death is so original, I will not spoil it for those who have yet to watch. Needless to say, time slows down, and I have never seen such a powerful idea for that climactic moment.
It has struck me in the past that if you don't have any good ideas to write a great story, another option is to find a great story and try your hand at telling it your way. Here Lin-Manuel knocks it out of the park. Sure, Hamilton's story is magic with his writing. There is no guarantee that even a good story is enough in a writer's hands.
So how would the story look if a woman had her story told? Who would the story about? What if Hamilton was the story of Elizabeth? What do you do about the dearth of historical data when the story, even today, is written about males for males, even by females.
What would a musical look like about Kim Campbell? Marie Curie? Irma LaVasseur? Suffragettes? Wives who stood behind their important husbands? Victims of sexual abuse? Rebels? Ordinary unsuccessful women at a certain era?
What I think is that an all woman cast would not be the same draw, and that troubles me a lot. I know I am mistaken by many men, but also women as NOT the doctor, because of my gender. I know that I would rather watch men's basketball and tennis than women's. Ninja warrior and the Olympics are a relief in those exceptions.
I had a flash on a zoom meeting with friends that we could all share our experiences as they hold significant jobs in many essential businesses, and solve some of the world's problems, but instead we spend another week listening to how to clean the house, and how great their families' meals are, and the new gym regime. We have our equality sometimes at work, but not in the rest of our life. Is it learned helplessness?
So I go to bed with lots of ideas and inspiration and frustration, but I can singularly applaud and recommend this tremendous work of art called Hamilton. Bravo! Brava!
EDITOR'S NOTE:
I have watched the musical so much that I have to watch my download monthly limit only 4 days into the month! Fortunately my brother mentioned the possibility of downloading to my phone after I looked at buying the soundtrack, but the audio wasn't the same. This way I only have to download data once, and I can continue to feed my addiction of this earworm of theatre. I have also found the script:
Act I and
Act II. I persuaded Princess Pirate to watch the first scene, and the King George scene "You'll be back" that is followed by "Right Hand Man", which she asked to keep watching when it came to it. Both scenes are genius! To have a a genius script filled out with brilliant acting (and directing?) is over-the-top. Hilarious and true with the subtlest and most flamboyant of expressions! Jonathon Groff is amazing!
Other fascinations: A play exists called Hamilton based in 1917, and a movie called Alexander Hamilton was produced in 1931. Lin-Manuel Miranda was reading Alexander Hamilton by Ron Chernow, and by the second chapter he felt he was reading the story of a hiphop artist, and "hip-hop songs started rising from the page", just as the story reminded him of his dad, and the immigrant story emerged.
Notable are the stats of the word counts - 144 words per minute with a total of 20, 520 total, with Phantom of the Opera at the next highest word count at 6,789, averaging 68 words a minute.
The Hamilton Letters didn't have everything I was looking for, but the
Reynold's Papers are a great example as how obfuscating his writing could be, when he was passionately trying to be clear, and it was fun to see his commentary on the Quebec Bill!
So many great lines, but to quote the first president:
"Dying is easy, young man. Living is harder. ", says George Washington.
"Winning was easy, young man. Governing's harder."